The little snort coming from the Demin did not go unnoticed, but Aiolos let it slide. Between the drink and the complete difference in their demeanors and backgrounds, as well as Nolan's considerably greater experience and a likelihood of looking down on Aiolos for his youth, he was sure they wouldn't see eye-to-eye on this issue no matter what. And that was all right with Aiolos. Like stone itself, Demin Elementals tended toward stubbornness and preferred to voice their opinions like beating people with boulders; Typh Elementals, on the other hand, wound their way around the firmer opinions of others, gave little care when others disagreed with them, and picked things up as they went on their way like the wind picked up sand, leaves, and other debris.
Nolan raised a rather good point in response, of course. Why should someone keep their identity hidden just because it was different from someone else? It was true, as Aiolos had already said, that discrimination and persecution were almost guaranteed to fall on them if the Council decided to publicise their existence. That wasn't the way things should be, but it was the way things were. But how would most wizards and witches know any better, learn tolerance as the correct way to live, if they weren't presented with an opportunity such as theirs? Times had changed. Grindelwald, and Voldemort - twice - had tried to divide wizardkind by touting banal philosophies of prejudice and exclusivity, and ultimately they had been not just defeated, but their ideals rejected. Surely people were more accepting of the wide varieties of magic in the world now.
On the other hand... Nolan certainly was persuasive, but where he said that wand users "think of themselves as superior," Aiolos couldn't help but think that the Demin thought of Elementals as being superior - and Aiolos believed them to be equal, but different. As he sat there staring into the night sky and thinking, surprisingly calmly, about all these things, he became aware that he had not actually answered Nolan's question. In the awkward pause that followed, a small trickle of the Demin's energy created a localised quake. Aiolos felt uneasy, but understood; he had done literally the same thing moments ago.
Nolan went on, but abruptly the tenor of his thoughts had changed. This seemed like where Nolan had been going all along. The Council, Aiolos thought uneasily. Were they controlling all other Elementals? Were they treating their underlings like "a petulant child"? Was he "hiding" in the Inverness complex? Even though Nolan asked Aiolos a direct question after all of these rhetorical ones, Aiolos couldn't answer right away. Sure, the Demin was drunk... but he raised valid points. He had to think, and deeply.
First, control. At first he thought, Of course they aren't controlling us. They're benevolently overseeing us. And of their treatment of the Rogues? They are responding. The Rogues acted in direct defiance of the Council's wisdom. Our policy regarding the Rogues is one of response and defence, nothing more. But did he ever do anything against the Council's wisdom? I've never been spoken to about my personal way of communing with my Element. Strange looks and inquiries, sure, but no admonishment. Still, the word "control" did nothing to alleviate the continuous disquiet that Nolan had planted in his mind.
Second, treatment. Aiolos thought Nolan probably had used the wrong turn of phrase because of his alcohol intake, but he was pretty sure he took the Demin's meaning. It's not that he thinks we are the petulant children being calmly disciplined by the Council; he thinks of the Council as the ones who have to have it their way. Which goes back to the idea of control. But they listen to us, respect us, make us feel like part of the community. An odd question popped into his mind: Why doesn't Nolan feel like part of the community? Has the Council started shutting him out, after they had worked to free him from Azkaban?
Third, hiding? No. Aiolos had chosen his path. He had wanted to be near his Elemental Shrine, to drink in its mysteries and really become one with Typh. And the other ranks? Zealots were free to come and go. They were asked to do work for the Council, not truly demanded. Advocates were given training while still allowed to live their own lives, should they so choose (Aiolos had not). Discipli were expected to be educated in their Elemental prowess, just as they were expected to be educated in magic in general at their schools.
"I just don't agree with that," Aiolos finally said to Nolan. "I don't feel trapped, or controlled, or co-opted here. But, my experience has been far different from yours, and also far shorter." He turned and looked the Demin dead in the eye. "What have you seen that makes you believe this - and should I be concerned, going forward?"