Oh, fuck.
He blinked at her as she spoke, her eyes welling, her tone falling. He’d gotten pissy, sure, because he had all but forgotten about the nature of this evening until he was confronted with it face to face. It was there, gleaming beside her collarbones, beautiful and bright. He wished he hadn’t noticed it. He’d tried to forget about it. He shouldn’t have said anything at all. “Erika, I —“ he tried, but something in her had changed. Shifted. She was looking at him like a monster and suddenly he was feeling like one.
She’d saved him, she’d thrown up that ward. She’d shown him how to leap from the building and plunge into the canal. She’d been the real adventurer, he was just along for the ride. She’d won, he meant that in every sense. She was the victor. The box was hers. It just felt like shit to know that he’d failed, to have to question whether this meal between them, this friendship between them, was just part of the game too. But as she unhinged the cord from her neck he knew that he’d made a terrible misjudgment. It wasn’t the first time and it certainly wouldn’t be the last.
The necklace was sitting on the table, ripe for the taking, and he didn’t want it. Not one bit. Not if this is what it meant, if this was the cost to bear. “I didn’t mean it like that — ” he explained, shaking his head. She was rising, touching his arm. Kissing his cheek. He blushed, just a little, and felt an overwhelming sense of panic surging in his chest. It was just like before, when the water was rising and they were both truly at risk for losing everything. He’d fought then, as hard as he could, but he couldn’t save her. The river had whisked her away and tried its damnedest to drown him, too.
“Erika, wait, Erika!” he hollered, rising promptly from the table as the girl turned and began to run. He grabbed the necklace — obviously not wanting to leave it around all these muggles — and was affronted by their server. The handsome man had become very pushy, now, believing them to be bouncing before paying the bill. “Please, I need to — you don’t understand,” Pierce barked angrily, the man’s furious Italian whizzing past his ears like bullets. “Take it, Jesus, take it!” Pierce shouted, emptying his pockets onto the table. The man was satisfied and he ran, having egregiously overpaid the bill. He didn’t cate. Money came and went. But this — this was a mess he might not be able to clean up tomorrow.
He was barreling as fast as he knew how, his legs sprawling and long as onlookers murmured at his recklessness. He saw only pieces, the hint of baby blue fabric spinning around the corner. The lingering scent of her perfume. He was running on pure instinct and, of course, luck to boot. “Erika! For God’s sake Erika!” he bellowed, pigeons fluttering all about as he booked it through the grand piazza. He saw her, finally, the girl stopping and crying. It broke him, his lungs burning for air as he closed the gap like a wounded puppy.
“Stop, please, Erika — stop,” he begged, pleading, bending down to be closer to her level as she looked so absolutely stricken. To see this at all was painful, to know he’d caused it was like a fatal blow. He wanted to touch her, reach out for her, but he was certain that wouldn’t end well. So he spoke softly, desperately, begging her in every way he knew to relent. He stood, all at once, shaking out his limbs as a few people stopped to examine the situation. This was a private moment, albeit it in public, and they appeared to be developing an audience.
“Alright, c’mon,” he said, motioning for her to come hither. His tone was different, lighter, pained but less unsure. “Stand up, you’ve got this,” he said, jumping back and forth on his tiptoes as he rolled his neck. He was getting loose, limber. “C’mon, right here, right in this area,” he said, patting his right cheek. “This, this will hurt the most — right on the cheekbone,” he said, patting the raised plane. “Right in the middle, the hollow, that’ll hurt too but probably not as much,” he offered. “A slap would be best for me, really, open palm — but this is about you,” he conceded, nodding despite his nerves. “If you want to punch, close that fist up, I won’t stop you,” he said with a nod. “Just… try to avoid this,” he offered, a little bit of comedy beneath his words. Playfulness. Old Pierce.
“This is the money maker,” he said, motioning to his face, “and a split lip, broken nose — well, that’ll take some serious mending charms and we all know that without my looks I”m pretty much spent,” he teased with a half-smile. He stood still then, strong and true. His offer still on the table. “C’mon,” he said, “just hit me. Give me a whop,” he said plainly. “I’m an ass,” he said bluntly, no beating around the bush. He swallowed hard, the small group now eagerly awaiting to watch what happened next. Pierce was nervous, but at least she couldn’t apparate away on him. Not here, with an audience. Despite their magic and their secrets in this moment they were just Pierce and just Erika.
“Just… make it quick?” he said, closing his eyes and wincing, prepared for the blow. After a moment, he peeked one eye, slowly — cautiously. He was ready for it. He just hoped it would make her feel better.