Lorin turned away from him to hide the tears that stung the corners of her eyes. It was a complicated mess, and he was right about that. He just didn't seem to understand any of what she was feeling, any of what she'd been thinking, or any of what she wanted. She couldn't blame him, though, because she didn't understand half of it herself. She wasn't standing there in love with him, pining. She had never felt romantic for him before this, but hearing him agree that he didn't feel for her felt like a knife in the chest. Why wasn't she good enough? Wasn't she beautiful? Wasn't she smart, wasn't she well-behaved, wasn't she interesting?
Of course she wasn't. That was the only logical conclusion. She wasn't good enough for Harvey, and the reality of the situation cut deep. It had been her worry all along, though she wasn't sure the reason for it. She knew what she had hoped, what she had wanted. As she grew, she needed him to fill the gaps differently than she had before. If anyone could give her this, she thought it would have been him. He'd never let her down before this, and now she was letting him down.
Lorin had always been a complicated girl. She was hard as nails on the outside, tough to know and difficult to affect. She kept her emotions far from anything and made every move with careful, calculated precision. Deep down, however, she was very vulnerable, hurt, and searching for approval—especially from members of the male gender. Her father had been distant when she was a child, for reasons Lorin had yet to fully understand, but it affected her completely. She sought out that attention from her brother, Theoren, and was appeased when he was there to dote lavishly upon her, praising her and looking at her like she was his sun and stars.
When Theoren left for Hogwarts, it left Lorin miserable and desperate to find that feeling from someone else. That was when she met Harvey. Harvey, in his youth, had taken Theoren's spot. He had bridged the gap and he had followed her without question and for so long.
Then, the foundation of Lorin's world turned when she allowed her anger and spite to make decisions for her. She was too young to understand what she was doing when she took her first lover at thirteen. She wasn't ready for the changes it would make to her, to the way she saw the world. She learned that sex had power over men, the power to make them do ridiculous things, and the power to gain their full and undivided attention, and she reveled in this power. She took it into herself as an advantage, and she held it over everything in her life. She never realized how much this killed in her—an innocence that she would never be able to get back, and her ability to form relationships based on anything else.
This complicated her relationship with Harvey a hundredfold. She didn't want him like a lover, not really, but she wanted him to be her boyfriend. That was very apparent to her, though the reason remained elusive. She could barely scratch the surface of it. If he was her boyfriend, she would know what she meant to him. She'd know she was admired, cared for. She would know that he didn't plan to leave. She would know that he valued her more than the other girls and differently than his other friends. She could be happy with him, she thought. He wasn't Seth, but that didn't matter. She had been to afraid to even reach out to the older boy over the holiday. She was prepared to give him up for the possibility of something stable with someone she trusted.
Conall had offered her this once, and she had turned it down because she didn't trust him—Harvey was different. He was her most trusted, oldest friend. She thought that she could relax with him, grow comfortable, grow old. She thought that the comfort of their relationship would someday make her love him the way she could never love Conall.
In this moment, however, she ached with the memory of someone who wanted to keep her. She didn't know if she'd ever find that again, and she doubted it. If Harvey, who once gave her anything she asked, could not give her his heart—who could? Seth hadn't written, hadn't called, hadn't come to throw rocks at her window..
She wiped her face with the back of her hand, still looking away.
“It was silly.” She agreed, though not to what he was really saying. He meant that it was silly to be upset. To her, it was silly to think one kiss would change anything. “But I didn't do it for comfort. If you know me at all, you know why I did it... and you know why I'm ashamed.” She managed.
“...but you're right. It is silly, to think that somehow you'd still be mine after all these years. I should have just let you go when you pulled away, but..” Her voice cracked. The tears threatened to fall again.
“...but tightening my grip comes easier to me than letting go, Harvey. It always has.” This felt like a goodbye. In some ways, it was. If anyone had outgrown anyone, he had outgrown her, and that was a bitter pill for Lorin to swallow. She didn't want him to leave her. She still needed him, even if he no-longer needed her. If he left, she had no idea what she would do.
“I thought that if...” She hesitated. “If I kissed you, that you would come back.” She couldn't believe she said the words aloud, them giving up so much of the cacophony in her chest.
“It was silly.” She repeated. “You were already gone.”
She finally turned back towards him. “Do you really want to be here, Harvey, or do you just feel obligated? I didn't think you would notice that I wasn't speaking to you. I didn't think you'd come. I thought you would've taken advantage of the out that I gave you.” She confessed.
“Do you love me?” She demanded. Of course he did. There was more than one kind of love, but Lorin couldn't wrap her head around it. Some part of her knew it. He said it in everything but the words themselves, but she didn't believe it. “If you do... why..” She couldn't say it. Her voice cracked again. Why? Why did he leave? Why wasn't she good enough?