Jonathan dutifully paid attention to Regan's account, including her verbal and physical tics, trusting the quill to write the letter of what she said, along with the obvious pauses and occasional editorialisation. He nodded along with several items as she went along with her story, fully aware of the foul that Regan was referring to. In truth, although it was the Falcons' performance that Jonathan had been there to analyse, the Bats had been under his scrutiny for a few weeks now for this type of behaviour. Whether they were beginning to perform poorly because they had decided to play dirty, or they had decided to play dirty because they were beginning to perform poorly, Jonathan wasn't sure. They were certainly much sloppier, talentwise, than they had been at the beginning of the season in January.
But again, Regan was right. Had Jonathan still been refereeing, as he had done before becoming the Assistant Department Head in 1995 and then the Department Head in 1998, the Bats would have been called not only for the cobbing incident and the blagging foul declared later in the game, but also for blatching, stooging, and an attempt at subtle haversacking. He didn't share with Regan that he had already launched another, separate investigation into his referees for the match and was planning on making the entire roster of umpires re-take the Q.O.R.E. to prove they actually knew what the rules were. The business between the Department Head and the Falmouth Seeker was that of the Transfiguration incident, not an entire culture of lazy officiating.
The biggest, most obvious offence of all was the violation of the British Ministry's Rule #6: "Players may take their wands onto the pitch, but they must not be used on or against any players, any players' broomsticks, the referee, any of the four balls, or the spectators
⁽¹⁾." In truth, Jonathan wanted to call for the immediate removal of Burney O’Kernaghan from the Ballycastle roster, but unfortunately his Ministry Department only controlled the schedule of matches, the playing and moderation of games, and the coordination of playoffs. All Quidditch clubs were privately owned and the way the teams made money was by having players that fans wanted to pay to watch play. It was an issue that came up practically every year at the International Confederation's Annual Quidditch Meeting, and had never changed yet. Jonathan simply didn't have the authority to include a player ban authorisation on the agreement that teams signed to be part of the British & Irish League - not if he still wanted the ICW's support behind him.
Something Regan pointed out was something that Jonathan had been wondering about. The choice of an Irish setter? A lot of people might think it was a very clear shot and, as the Seeker pointed out, it seemed like it took some forethought. After all, Quinn Regan was the only pureblooded Irish on the Falcons' roster. But on the other hand, Ballycastle was the only team from Northern Ireland that participated in the League, and O’Kernaghan did not seem like a particularly forethinking person. There was no denying his skill as a Chaser (when he played clean) but it was always odd seeing him playing that position, built as he was more like a Beater and with a sloping Neanderthal forehead. Jonathan made a mental note to look into that aspect of the incident and see what he
claimed he had been thinking when he did it.
At Regan's last question, Jonathan shrugged casually. "As I said, anything you wish to add, I will include in my report. I won't pretend this is a personal visit as we haven't really ever talked until today, but for what it's worth I wish I could do more for you, and more against the Bats." He turned up his hands in a gesture of helplessness that his face made plain he wished he didn't feel. "So if you believe you can provide enough concrete information to warrant a stronger punishment, I encourage you to do so."