Isaac had realized it before, but as they spoke about music, pop versus rock, dreams versus gypsy, and rumors versus mirage, he hit him again. They were entirely different; they didn’t like the same things, listen to the same music, probably had contrary values when it came to just about everything, but one thing they did have in common was the need to argue. No matter what they were talking about, Isaac had realized they never agreed. If he said one thing, she’d say no this instead, and vice versa. He caught himself doing it all the time, sometimes because he believed what he was saying, but most of the time, he couldn’t have cared less either way. Mostly it was an effort to buy time to talk to her for a while longer, and he’d realized that, too.
“No, I am saying it because your wrong,†Isaac said, aware of his motivations and that Magnolia was right, and saying it anyway, and then he smiled. Magnolia changed the record, and Isaac nodded as Second Hand News started to play. She came to sit next to him on the floor, and he was quiet as they listened for a moment. “Lindsay Buckingham is way better than Stevie-fucking-Nix,†he added as she pulled her knees toward her, and Isaac felt himself getting into the music. It was poppy and catchy, and it wormed its way into his mind, but he didn’t fight it.
By the end of the song, he tapped his fingers on his knee, but the teenager had not noticed. It was catchy, and then Dreams started playing, and Isaac recognized the starting riffs quickly. These beats didn’t worm into his mind, but he felt like it might puncture his soul, and then Stevie started singing, and Isaac tilted his head back again, eyes closing, and his shoulder brushed against Magnolia’s. He stilled, his shoulder still against hers, and just listened quietly for a while.